Skip to content

FPR · First Precedent Research
2026 FPR EDC 13 · https://firstprecedent.org/doctrines/discharge-of-surety-by-variance

DC-0210Doctrines · Contract · Editorial draft · 2026 FPR EDC 13

FPR Editors31 October 2026 · 3,981 words

Discharge of Surety by Variance

Under section 133 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a variance in the terms of the contract between creditor and principal debtor, made without the surety's consent, discharges the surety as to transactions after the variance; the rule protects the surety's right to be bound only to the risk undertaken, it does not reach mere internal bookkeeping that changes no term, and English authority excepts alterations that are self-evidently unsubstantial or beneficial.

Abstract

A surety promises to answer for a particular contract. If creditor and debtor change that contract behind the surety's back, the surety is no longer answering for the risk accepted. Section 133 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 gives the rule statutory form. This entry sets out the section and its illustrations; the English source in Holme v. Brunskill; the strict construction of guarantees in State of Maharashtra v. M.N. Kaul; what counts as a variance, with Amrit Lal Goverdhan Lalan v. State Bank of Travancore and the Madras decision in S. Perumal Reddiar v. Bank of Baroda; the distinct issue of alteration of the guarantee instrument itself in M.S. Anirudhan v. Thomco's Bank Ltd.; and how the section relates to sections 134 to 137, to continuing guarantees and to clauses giving advance consent.


I. The rule

Section 133

1A surety’s undertaking is measured by the contract guaranteed. Section 133 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 provides:

Any variance, made without the surety’s consent, in the terms of the contract between the principal debtor and the creditor, discharges the surety as to transactions subsequent to the variance.Indian Contract Act, 1872, s. 133, as set out in S. Perumal Reddiar v. Bank of Baroda, AIR 1981 Mad 180.

2The section has four elements: a change in the terms of the principal contract, made between creditor and debtor, without the surety’s consent, and an effect confined to later transactions. Each deserves attention, and the last often receives too little. A surety who has already become liable for transactions before the variance stays liable for those. The section’s words point forward, which is significant for a running account or a continuing guarantee. Where the contract is a single indivisible transaction, on the other hand, there may be nothing left over to which the guarantee can still attach once the terms have changed.

3The statute’s illustrations show this range. They include a surety for a bank manager whose salary and responsibilities are changed by agreement with the bank without the surety’s consent, and a guarantee of a loan to be made on a fixed date which the creditor advances earlier. The common point is that the surety undertook a defined obligation and the obligation was changed.

Why the rule exists

4The rationale is contractual. A surety is often described as a favoured debtor. In State of Maharashtra v. M.N. Kaul, the Supreme Court said that a guarantor “cannot be made liable for more than he has undertaken” and recalled Lord Westbury’s words in Blest v. Brown: “you bind him to the letter of his engagement. Beyond the proper interpretation of that engagement you have no hold upon him.”State of Maharashtra v. M.N. Kaul, AIR 1967 SC 1634 (Bench: M. Hidayatullah and C.A. Vaidialingam JJ.), quoting Blest v. Brown, (1862) 4 De G F & J 367, 376.

5The same passage notes that these observations have been recalled in cases of guarantee by the Judicial Committee and the Supreme Court, referring among others to Pratapsing Moholalbhai v. Keshavlal Harilal Setalvad and to M.S. Anirudhan v. Thomco’s Bank Ltd. The creditor and the debtor are free to change their bargain. They may not keep the surety bound to the new one without asking.

II. The English source

Holme v. Brunskill

6The modern common law rule comes from Holme v. Brunskill. Cotton L.J.’s statement is quoted in the Supreme Court’s judgment in Anirudhan:

The true rule in my opinion is, that if there is any agreement between the principals with reference to the contract guaranteed, the surety ought to be consulted, and that, if he has not consented to the alteration, although in cases where it is without inquiry evident that the alteration is unsubstantial, or that it cannot be otherwise than beneficial to the surety, the surety may not be discharged;Holme v. Brunskill, (1878) 3 QBD 495 (Cotton L.J.), as quoted in M.S. Anirudhan v. Thomco’s Bank Ltd., AIR 1963 SC 746.

7It continues that if it is not self-evident that the alteration is unsubstantial, or one which cannot be prejudicial to the surety, the court “will not, in an action against the suerty, go into an inquiry as to the effect of the alteration”. The surety does not have to prove actual prejudice. The creditor must show that the change could not hurt the surety.

8The discussion in Anirudhan notes that this was not unanimous in Holme: Brett L.J. dissented, observing that the doctrine of release of sureties was carried far enough. It also records a difference between Lord Westbury’s stricter rule, under which any change is enough, and that of Cotton L.J. It treats the law as now accepting that unsubstantial alterations which are to the benefit of the surety do not release the surety.

The text of section 133 and the exception

9Section 133 contains no express exception for insubstantial or beneficial changes. The exception comes from the English case law through its discussion in the Indian decisions. A careful statement of the position in India should mark this difference. A court applying the section can draw on Holme to read “variance” as a change of substance, but a creditor should not rely on the exception where there is any doubt, since Cotton L.J. limited it to cases where the matter is evident without inquiry.

III. What is a variance

Not every entry in a ledger

10There must be a change in the terms of the contract. Amrit Lal Goverdhan Lalan v. State Bank of Travancore gives the clearest illustration from the Supreme Court. The Bank agreed to open a cash credit account up to Rs. 1,00,000 secured by pledged goods, and the appellant guaranteed it. The surety argued that certain entries in the Bank’s account books showed the credit limit had been changed. The Court rejected this:

The entries in the books of account were mere internal instructions not legally binding on the respondents, and in view of the formal record in the original agreement and letter of guarantee, there could not leave been a variation in the terms without a proper written agreement, Therefore, there was no variance in the terms of the contract between the creditor and the principal debtor and the provisions of s. 133 of the Act were not attracted.Amrit Lal Goverdhan Lalan v. State Bank of Travancore, AIR 1968 SC 1432, (1968) 3 SCR 724 (V. Ramaswami J.), reported headnote.

11The surety succeeded on a different ground, section 141, to the extent of goods lost through the Bank’s negligence. The decision shows that a surety who pleads section 133 must point to an agreed change and not merely to the way the creditor administered the account.

Alterations in blank forms

12A surety’s complaint may concern the document itself, particularly where a printed form with blanks is used. In S. Perumal Reddiar v. Bank of Baroda, the Madras High Court dealt with a deed of guarantee in which blanks had been filled. The Court held that the alterations rendered the deed of guarantee unenforceable under section 133. It also accepted the concern that a contrary view would be “giving a free hand to the Bank to substitute any onerous condition in the blank spaces”.S. Perumal Reddiar, AIR 1981 Mad 180. The reasoning is useful practical guidance, but this is a High Court decision on its particular facts. It sits on the border between variance of the principal contract, which section 133 addresses directly, and alteration of the guarantee instrument.

IV. Alteration of the guarantee instrument

M.S. Anirudhan v. Thomco’s Bank

13Anirudhan is sometimes cited as a decision on section 133 in which a beneficial variance left the surety bound. It is better understood as a decision on material alteration of a written instrument, and it was decided by a divided Bench. The principal debtor, Shankaran, wanted an overdraft. The appellant signed a guarantee with a limit of Rs. 25,000. The Bank would only accept a guarantee for Rs. 20,000, so Shankaran altered the figure, without the appellant’s knowledge, and gave it back to the Bank. When sued on a guarantee of Rs. 20,000, the appellant pleaded that the alteration discharged him.

14By majority, the Court held that he was not discharged. The reasons differed:

Held, (per Kapur and Hidayatullah, JJ., Sarkar, J., dissenting), that the appellant was not discharged from his liability under the contract of guarantee.M.S. Anirudhan, AIR 1963 SC 746, 1963 Supp (1) SCR 63, reported headnote.

15Kapur J. reasoned that Shankaran was acting for the appellant when he made the change, since it was at his instance that the appellant was standing surety and the appellant had handed him the deed to give to the Bank. The plea of material alteration therefore failed, because the document was not altered while in the promisee’s possession. Hidayatullah J. reasoned that the document was not materially altered because it was not changed in a way that altered its nature: it reduced the liability of the surety and of the co-executant. He also held that the surety, having held Shankaran out as his agent, was estopped. Sarkar J. dissented. The altered document was not binding, in his view, and the unaltered one could not establish the contract sued on, since the Bank had refused to accept it.

16The point for section 133 is limited. Anirudhan discusses the approach of Holme to unsubstantial or beneficial changes, but its facts concerned a change in the guarantee and not in the contract between creditor and debtor. It should not be read as a general licence for creditors to vary terms because the variation seems helpful. The principal contract was not being changed in Anirudhan at all.

V. Neighbouring provisions

Sections 134 to 137

17Section 133 sits within a group of provisions, and it is important to place a dispute under the correct one. Section 134 discharges the surety where the creditor contracts with the debtor to release the debtor, or by any act or omission whose legal consequence is the debtor’s discharge. Section 135 discharges the surety where the creditor contracts with the debtor to compound, to give time or not to sue, unless the surety assents. Section 136 preserves the surety’s liability where the agreement to give time is with a third person and not with the debtor. Section 137 provides that mere forbearance to sue, or to enforce any other remedy, does not discharge the surety.

18Amrit Lal illustrates the same care under section 135: what really constitutes a promise to give time, the Court said, is an extension of the period at which, by the contract, the debtor was originally liable to pay. So an indulgence that the creditor gave without a binding promise did not discharge the surety under that provision.

19A change in interest rates, repayment dates or the amount of a facility may fall under section 133 if it is a change agreed between creditor and debtor. A creditor who merely waits, without any agreement, falls within section 137 and does not discharge the surety.

Sections 139 and 141

20Section 139 deals with an act inconsistent with the surety’s rights, or an omission to do something the creditor’s duty to the surety requires, where the surety’s eventual remedy against the debtor is thereby impaired. Section 141 deals with the loss of a security. These also protect the surety, but they turn on a different event and sometimes have a different consequence: under section 141, discharge is only to the extent of the value of the security. A surety in doubt should plead them in the alternative, as the guarantor in Amrit Lal did to good effect.

The continuing guarantee

21Section 129 defines a continuing guarantee as one that extends to a series of transactions, and section 130 lets the surety revoke it as to future transactions by notice. In this setting, the words of section 133 have a precise effect. The surety’s liability for transactions before the variance remains, and the discharge takes effect for what follows it. A running banking account can make it difficult to divide earlier and later transactions, but the statute directs the court to attempt that division and does not automatically release the surety entirely.

VI. Consent

Consent is the answer to the section

22Section 133 only applies to a variance “made without the surety’s consent”. If the surety agrees, either at the time or afterwards, no question of discharge arises. Banks therefore commonly take the surety’s signature on sanction letters or renewals, and directors who guarantee a company’s debts often sign those documents in another capacity. Whether signature in one capacity amounts to consent in the other is a matter of fact and construction.

Advance consent

23Guarantee forms often contain clauses by which the surety agrees in advance that the creditor and debtor may vary the facility, extend time or release securities without affecting the guarantee. Section 128 allows a contract to alter co-extensive liability, and the principle in M.N. Kaul means courts begin with the terms of the guarantee. In principle, therefore, a surety can consent in advance. An example of the courts considering such terms is the letter of guarantee in Amrit Lal, where clause 5 allowed the Bank to enforce the guarantee notwithstanding any other security held, though the Court read the clause narrowly and held that it did not exclude section 141.

24That construction shows the limit. Courts read such clauses against the party relying on them, in keeping with the rule that a surety is bound only to the letter of the engagement. A creditor seeking to rely on a broad clause should expect it to be read closely, and should not assume that general words will authorise any change, however onerous.

Pleading and proof

25The surety who relies on section 133 has to identify the term that was changed and the date, and to plead lack of consent. Once a change is shown, Holme places the practical burden on the creditor to show that the change is obviously insubstantial or could not be other than beneficial, because the court will not inquire into its effect otherwise. Because discharge applies only to later transactions, a careful surety will also analyse the account into the sums before and after the change, and a careful creditor will do the same in the alternative.

VII. Performance and variance

Pratapsing and the underlying principle

26The Privy Council’s decision in Pratapsing Moholalbhai v. Keshavlal Harilal Setalvad took the law a step further than section 133’s words. Sureties guaranteed an advance of Rs. 1,25,000 to be made on the security of four properties. The mortgagees in fact advanced Rs. 1,00,000 on the security of three. They did so at the request of the principal debtor, but the sureties were not consulted. Their Lordships said that the sureties could not be held liable “in respect of this performance, which was not what they contracted to guarantee”, and they went on:

The principle is that the surety, like any other contracting party, cannot be held bound to something for which he has not contracted.Pratapsing Moholalbhai v. Keshavlal Harilal Setalvad, (1934-35) 62 IA 23, AIR 1935 PC 21, as reported at (1935) 37 Bom LR 315.

27They considered that the law had been “somewhat obscured by the emphasis laid in the cases on an agreement between the parties to vary the terms of the original agreement”. The real question is whether what was done is what was guaranteed. If it is not, the surety is not bound, whether or not there was any formal agreement to vary. Nor does section 133 alter the basic position. It cannot, the Board said, “operate to alter the primary law of the contract of guarantee that the promisee must show performance before he can hold the promisor to his promise”. The same judgment quotes Blest v. Brown: a surety may say, “The contract is no longer that for which I engaged to be surety; you have put an end to the contract that I guaranteed, and my obligation, therefore, is at an end.”

A single obligation and a series

28The Bombay High Court, whose decision reached the Privy Council in that case, had said that section 133 contemplates a contract of the kind defined as a continuing guarantee in section 129. It reasoned that in a guarantee of one single point, “there could be no question of certain transactions being prior to the variance and certain other transactions being subsequent thereto”.Keshavlal Harilal Setalvad v. Pratapsing Moholalbhai Sheth, AIR 1932 Bom 168, (1932) 34 Bom LR 167. The Privy Council found it unnecessary to decide whether the section was intended to affect a guarantee of one obligation. It is enough that the principle above would then govern.

29This helps with the common distinction between two cases. Where a guarantee covers one term loan and the terms are changed before repayment, there may be no separate later transactions, and the surety may be released altogether. Where a guarantee covers a running cash credit account, a change at some point in the account leaves the earlier balance and affects what follows.

The facts of Holme v. Brunskill

30Holme v. Brunskill itself shows why the courts refuse to measure the effect of a change. A surety guaranteed the return of a flock of sheep by a tenant at the end of a farm lease. Landlord and tenant later agreed, without telling the surety, that the tenant would give up a field in exchange for a reduction in rent. When the sheep were returned in poor condition, the landlord sued the surety, arguing that the arrangement had done the surety no harm. The surety was held discharged. As Cotton L.J.’s statement shows, unless it is evident without inquiry that the alteration is unsubstantial or cannot be other than beneficial, the court will not go into the question of its effect.

VIII. Recurring banking disputes

Enhancement of a credit limit

31A frequent case is a cash credit facility of a fixed amount, guaranteed by a surety, which the bank later increases at the borrower’s request without telling the surety. The first question is what the guarantee says. If it caps the surety’s liability at a stated sum, an argument is open that the further credit is simply something for which the surety never promised to answer, and that the surety remains bound up to the ceiling. The contrary argument is that a larger exposure materially changes the borrower’s position and therefore the surety’s risk, particularly if the facility itself has been restructured. Section 133, with its reference to later transactions, gives a text for the narrower answer in the case of a running account, and Holme gives support for the broader one where the identity of the arrangement has changed. A careful adviser will not treat either view as beyond argument.

Interest rates

32The same approach applies to interest. A floating rate that moves according to a benchmark, under a clause in the contract guaranteed, is performance of the contract and not a change in it. The surety undertook that risk. A fixed rate which the bank and the borrower later agree to raise, or a fixed rate converted to a floating rate, is a change in the terms. Syndicate Bank v. R. Veeranna shows that a dispute on a bank’s unilateral raising of its rate can arise as an issue in a suit against a borrower and guarantors, the trial court there framing an issue on “Whether the plaintiff Bank is justified in unilaterally raising the rate of interest?”Syndicate Bank v. R. Veeranna, (2003) 2 SCC 15, AIR 2003 SC 2122 (Bench: Shivaraj V. Patil and Arijit Pasayat JJ.). The surety’s position turns on whether the change was within the contract.

Clauses giving advance consent

33State Bank of Saurashtra v. Chitranjan Rangnath Raja is a valuable example of how far clauses of this kind extend. Clause 5 of the letter of guarantee gave the bank a right to grant time or indulgence, to determine, enlarge or vary its credit, and to vary, exchange or take other securities or release any securities, without discharging the surety. Although that clause was wide, the Supreme Court held that it did not help the bank. The case was not one of giving time, varying credit or releasing security: “Release of security implies a volitional act on the part of the Bank. Loss on account of negligence cannot be equated with release.”State Bank of Saurashtra v. Chitranjan Rangnath Raja, (1980) 4 SCC 516, AIR 1980 SC 1528 (D.A. Desai J.), reported headnote.

34The decision of the Supreme Court commonly cited for upholding a surety’s advance waiver is Industrial Finance Corporation of India Ltd. v. Cannanore Spinning & Weaving Mills Ltd., (2002) 5 SCC 54. The usual reasoning is that sections 133 to 141 protect the surety personally, and that a person may give up a protection that exists for that person’s own benefit. The full text of that decision could not be consulted for this entry, and a reader should go to the report before relying on it. Read with State Bank of Saurashtra, it suggests the correct approach: the surety can consent in advance, and a court will then enforce what the surety actually agreed to, without extending it to anything else.

Practice for each side

35A surety defending a claim should call for the sanction letters, renewal letters, interest revision notices and ledgers, and should examine whether the limit was enhanced, the tenure rescheduled, the rate altered or a co-obligant released without the surety’s signature. Discovery under Order XI of the Code of Civil Procedure is the usual tool. The plea of discharge should be taken expressly in the written statement, as Order VIII Rule 2 requires for matters that would take the other side by surprise, and it should state the date of the change.

36A bank should obtain a written confirmation from each guarantor on every renewal or restructuring, acknowledging the revised limit and tenure. It should keep the document with the original guarantee. Where an unconsented change has happened, it should consider whether it can show that the change was evidently unsubstantial or beneficial. It should also consider which of the transactions came before the change, because liability for those remains.

IX. Anirudhan on the facts

37The facts of M.S. Anirudhan show how a change in the guarantee instrument can seem to help the surety, and yet raise a real question:

The appellant agreed to stand surety for an overdraft allowed by the respondent Bank to S. A blank form of guarantee was given by the Bank to S, who then had it filled up by the appellant stating the maximum amount which he guaranteed as Rs. 25000/-. When S brought the letter of guarantee duly signed by the appellant and himself to the Bank the latter refused to accept the guarantee up to that limit as it was not prepared to give S accommodation for a larger sum than Rs. 20000/- and wanted it to be limited to Rs. 20000/-.M.S. Anirudhan v. Thomco’s Bank Ltd., AIR 1963 SC 746, 1963 Supp (1) SCR 63, reported headnote.

38The principal debtor then made alterations in the letter, reducing the limit to Rs. 20,000, and gave it to the bank, without going back to the surety. In a suit on the guarantee, the appellant pleaded that the alteration discharged him. The majority rejected this. The reduction was in the surety’s favour, and it did not expose the surety to anything beyond what had been agreed. Sarkar J. dissented, as noted above.

39The case differs from the usual application of section 133, because the change was to the guarantee and not to the contract between creditor and debtor. It raises a separate question about a material alteration in the document itself. The outcome should not be read as saying that any change favourable to a surety is always harmless. A reduction of a limit may have effects for the way the account is run. The conclusion rests on the particular facts, on the absence of prejudice, and on the alteration being in the surety’s favour.

X. The effect of the words “as to transactions subsequent”

40The closing words of section 133 limit its operation. The surety is discharged “as to transactions subsequent to the variance”. For a guarantee of a single debt, a change in its terms will usually affect the whole of the surety’s liability, since there is only one transaction. For a continuing guarantee, such as one for a running account or for supplies over a period, the earlier transactions stand. The illustrations show this. A surety for a supply of goods who is not told of a change in the terms of later supplies remains liable for what has already been delivered. A surety who wishes to rely on the section should therefore plead when the variance took place, and show which part of the debt arose after it.

XI. The position today

41A variance under section 133 requires a change in the terms of the principal contract agreed between creditor and debtor without the surety’s consent. It discharges the surety only for transactions after the variance. Internal entries that do not alter the contract are not a variance. Mere forbearance is not a variance either, and it is dealt with under section 137. Indian decisions draw on Holme v. Brunskill in accepting that an alteration which is plainly unsubstantial or necessarily beneficial may not discharge the surety, though the statute does not state this exception. Consent, including consent given in advance in the guarantee, answers the section, but courts read such clauses strictly.

42The practical advice is the same for both sides. Every material change to a guaranteed facility should be taken to the surety for written consent. A creditor who does so removes the problem, and a surety who is asked knows exactly what is being undertaken.


History

  • Published · 31 October 2026

Nothing has been changed since publication. How FPR corrects a piece · Report an error


The editors wrote this draft to get the entry started. A student can claim the entry, rework the draft or start over, and the piece will then carry their name.

© 2026 First Precedent Research. Free to share and adapt with credit, for non-commercial use, under CC BY-NC 4.0. A published piece is changed only to correct an error, and each correction is listed under History. If the law changes, we add a linked afterword. Nothing on FPR is legal advice.

Found a mistake? Report an error, giving the paragraph number. If you are right, the text is corrected and the correction is recorded publicly.

SEEAlso in Contract

Everything in Contract

ELSEWHERECounterparts · the same question in other jurisdictions

No scholar has written on another country’s law here yet. Write a counterpart from your jurisdiction


Comments · 0

Sign in to comment. Comments are moderated.